Sugar City Homes under $500,000

Sugar City Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Sugar City, Idaho – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Madison County. Known for its charming small-town atmosphere and breathtaking natural beauty, Sugar City offers a delightful blend of rural tranquility and modern conveniences. With a population that embraces community spirit, you'll find friendly neighbors, local shops, and a vibrant sense of belonging.

Sugar City is perfectly situated near the stunning landscapes of the Teton Mountains and the scenic vistas of the Snake River. Outdoor enthusiasts will revel in the abundance of recreational activities available, from hiking and fishing to winter sports. The city is also conveniently located just a short drive from the bustling town of Rexburg, where you’ll find additional shopping, dining, and entertainment options.

For those looking to plant roots in this picturesque locale, Sugar City offers an impressive selection of homes under $500,000. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, a growing family, or seeking a peaceful retreat, you’ll discover a variety of charming properties that cater to diverse tastes and lifestyles. From cozy single-family homes to spacious townhouses, each residence is designed to provide comfort and warmth, making it easy to envision your future here.

Living in Sugar City means embracing a lifestyle that values community, nature, and affordability. With its welcoming ambiance and beautiful surroundings, it’s no wonder that so many are choosing to call Sugar City home. Come explore the possibilities and find your dream home in this enchanting Idaho town!

Newest Sugar City Homes under $500,000

1181 Country Rd, Sugar City
$495,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2189643 MLS
Welcome to your own piece of Idaho paradise! Located at 1181 Country Road in Sugar City, this beautiful 5-bedroom, 3-bath home sits on over 2 acres and offers incredible views of the majestic Tetons. With the Teton River within walking distance, you'll have easy access to some of the area's best outdoor recreation. The property also features an elk farm directly across the road, giving you a unique and scenic view right from your home. Outside, you'll find multiple outbuildings, including spaces for chickens, plus a fully fenced area designed for horses with existing stables. Whether you're looking for room to raise animals, enjoy the outdoors, or simply have some space to spread out, this property has it all. Enjoy peaceful country living while still being close to Sugar City and everything the surrounding area has to offer. Properties with this much land, these views, and this kind of setup don't come around often! Make sure to come check it out!

1181 Country Rd, Sugar City
314 Poppy St, Sugar City
$460,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2189616 MLS
Brand New Construction with fully landscaped yard. Welcome to this stunning new construction home offering 1,745 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. Featuring 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and a spacious 2-car garage, this home combines modern style, functionality, and comfort. The open-concept layout creates a seamless flow between the living, dining, and kitchen areas, making it perfect for everyday living and entertaining. Huge gravel side parking pad that can fit an RV or extra cars needing to be parked. Don't miss your chance to own a brand-new home that offers quality craftsmanship, modern amenities, and a desirable setting with beautiful scenery. Pictures are of a similar home that has been staged the main picture and the last few pictures are actually pictures of the home showing colors and finishes. Home is fully finished.

314 Poppy St, Sugar City
398 Poppy St, Sugar City
$499,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2189495 MLS
Brand New Construction with Fully Landscaped Backyard. Welcome to this stunning new construction home offering 1,905 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. Featuring 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a spacious 2-car garage, this home combines modern style, functionality, and comfort. The open-concept layout creates a seamless flow between the living, dining, and kitchen areas, making it perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen is complemented by a spacious butler's pantry, providing additional storage, prep space, and convenience. Enjoy beautiful views from the backyard, which will be fully landscaped, creating the perfect setting for relaxing or hosting gatherings. Don't miss your chance to own a brand-new home that offers quality craftsmanship, modern amenities, and a desirable setting with beautiful scenery.

398 Poppy St, Sugar City
337 Stillwater Ln, Sugar City
$366,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2189406 MLS
Set along the canal with no backyard neighbors, 337 Stillwater Lane offers a fresh take on new construction with a thoughtful layout and a setting that gives you a little more space from the homes around you. Direct access to the future walking park pathway system adds an easy connection to the outdoors and surrounding neighborhood. Inside, the main level is designed to feel open and connected, with the kitchen flowing naturally into the dining and living spaces. Clean designer finishes, stainless steel appliances, and upgraded LVP and carpet give the home a polished feel while keeping it comfortable for everyday living. A convenient half bath completes the main level. Upstairs, three bedrooms provide a private space to retreat, including a spacious primary suite with an upgraded, private, covered balcony. The primary bath features a freestanding soaking tub and separate shower, creating a comfortable place to unwind at the end of the day. Outside, the fully fenced and landscaped yard, complete with a sprinkler system, is ready to enjoy from the start. With modern finishes, thoughtful spaces, and a location that combines privacy with neighborhood convenience, 337 Stillwater Lane is a home designed to feel easy from the moment you walk in.

337 Stillwater Ln, Sugar City
2 Brandon Dr, Sugar City
$365,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2188908 MLS
Charming 1,400 sq. ft. home in the quiet community of Sugar City, situated on a manageable 0.19-acre lot ? just enough space without the heavy maintenance! This well maintained home features a brand new roof! Welcoming entryway leading into a bright, spacious living room with a large natural-light-filled window. Eat-in kitchen and dining area perfect for family meals and gatherings, featuring a cozy brick mantle, glass doors, and plenty of counter and storage space. Private primary bedroom and bathroom with a stand-up shower and large windows. Two additional spacious bedrooms and a full bathroom complete the main floor. Convenient single-level living plus a two-car garage for added functionality. Step outside to a fenced yard that includes a storage shed (with electricity), plenty of room for gardening, entertaining, pets, or simply enjoying the outdoors. This charming home with comfortable living spaces, easy maintenance, and the perfect sized yard is move in ready. Call today to see it!

2 Brandon Dr, Sugar City
431 S Idaho Ave, Sugar City
$409,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2188906 MLS
Single-level living in one of Sugar City's established neighborhoods! Built in 2019, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers 1,485 square feet of bright, open living space on a quarter-acre lot in Old Farm Estates. Step inside to extra-high ceilings, large windows, and an open great room that gives the home a spacious feel from the moment you walk in. The kitchen centers around a large granite island with plenty of room to gather, plus a walk-in pantry for the storage you actually need. The primary suite features a walk-in closet and tiled walk-in shower, while two additional bedrooms offer space for family, guests, or a home office. Everything is conveniently on one level, including the laundry, with no stairs to deal with. Out back, a covered patio extends the living space outdoors with plenty of yard to enjoy. Add in an attached two-car garage, a neighborhood park just down the street, quiet residential streets, Sugar-Salem schools, and Rexburg only about 10 minutes away. A newer home, a great-sized lot, and an easy floor plan in a location that's hard to beat!

431 S Idaho Ave, Sugar City
23 N Front St, Sugar City
$335,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2188755 MLS
This spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home features two levels of living space, an office, and a convenient 2-car garage. The home has been refreshed with fresh interior and exterior paint and new carpet throughout, giving the space a clean and updated feel. With a functional layout and plenty of room for comfortable living, this home offers a great opportunity in a desirable Sugar City location.

23 N Front St, Sugar City
3679 N 5000 E, Sugar City
$350,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2187233 MLS
Charming farm-style property in the heart of Sugar City offering space, functionality, and endless potential on a .8-acre lot. This well-loved older farmhouse blends character and practicality with already done updates with flooring, paint and the kitchen! A standout feature of the property is the large shop—fully set up for mechanical work with a dedicated oil change bay and welder hookups, making it ideal for hobbyists, small business use, or serious projects. Whether you're working on equipment, vehicles, or need extra storage, this shop delivers rare versatility. In addition to the main home and shop, the property includes a detached unit featuring a finished bedroom, perfect for guests, multigenerational living, a private office, or rental income potential. With nearly an acre of usable land, there is room for animals, gardening, parking, and outdoor living. The setting offers a small-town feel with open space and the convenience of nearby amenities. Opportunities like this—combining acreage, usable shop space, and additional living quarters—don't come up often in Sugar City. Bring your ideas and make this property your own.

3679 N 5000 E, Sugar City
274 W 4th S, Sugar City
$355,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2185606 MLS
Built in 2023, this well-maintained Peregrine townhome offers modern finishes and a functional layout. Main level features a powder room, comfortable living space, and an open kitchen/dining area with granite countertops, white cabinetry, and included stainless-steel appliances. Luxury vinyl plank flooring and quality carpet throughout. Upstairs includes 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and a convenient laundry area. Spacious primary suite with private bath featuring a freestanding tub and separate tiled walk-in shower. Low-maintenance exterior and attached 2-car garage. Located near schools, community park, and just minutes from Rexburg and BYU-Idaho. Great potential as an investment property or primary residence.

274 W 4th S, Sugar City
3774 Hwy 33, Sugar City
$339,500
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2182333 MLS
Looking for acreage, shop space, and room to spread out while staying close to Rexburg and Sugar City? This 1.45-acre property offers mountain and valley views, a 4-bedroom, 2-bath manufactured home on a permanent foundation with approximately 1,799 sq. ft., plus a large insulated two-bay shop with a separation wall and its own power meter—ideal for storage, hobbies, or workspace. Additional features include a circular driveway, RV/trailer parking, animal corrals, and new siding that has already been purchased and is included with the sale. CASH ONLY SALE: The property is located within a Special Flood Hazard Area, and the existing home foundation, garage, and shop do not currently meet required flood-elevation standards, limiting conventional financing options. A future buyer may have the ability to remove the existing home and build new or raise/modify the foundation and improvements to meet applicable elevation requirements, which could potentially allow for financing; buyer to independently verify requirements and financing options with the appropriate agencies and lender. Buyer and buyer's agent to verify all information, including flood zone/elevation requirements, property boundaries, zoning, and intended use.

3774 Hwy 33, Sugar City
676 Idaho Ave, Sugar City
$480,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2182082 MLS
Now offered for pre-sale, this thoughtfully designed home in Sugar City provides a strong opportunity for both owner-occupants and investors seeking long-term value. Buyers can secure a fully finished home prior to construction completion. Photos are of a similar finished unit; finishes and layout may vary. With 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, it offers plenty of space for everyday life and future possibilities. The main level features the primary suite with en-suite bath, a second bedroom, and a family room that anchors the home. Downstairs, the fully finished basement provides 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a bonus living room area, creating a flexible space for guests, hobbies, or potential rental income. Every detail has been carefully considered: durable LVP flooring, Level 2 quartz or granite countertops, quality cabinetry, warm wood accents, and designer lighting throughout. A fireplace upgrade is available, and energy-efficient systems help keep living comfortable and costs low. Just minutes from BYU–Idaho, Walmart, schools, and major retail corridors, this home combines convenience with community charm. A planned 6-acre city park nearby will offer recreation and enhance the neighborhood's long-term appeal. Make this your new home today!

676 Idaho Ave, Sugar City
458 S 3rd W Unit #458, Sugar City
$345,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2181296 MLS
Coveted END UNIT AVAILABLE! Welcome to 458 S 3rd W in the newer Targhee Townhome Subdivision in Sugar City, Idaho. This is a great open floor plan with many upgrades including granite countertops, a gas range, barn doors, dual sinks, and tile surround in the primary bathroom. The contemporary color scheme throughout combined with the high ceilings make this unit feel bright and open. The primary bedroom is nice sized and features a transom window and access to a flex space/room off the side which would make for a great office or nursery. Oversized, attached, garage stall and plus TWO additional parking spots on the pad outside the garage. Fully fenced private back patio space with access to open greenspace and playground area. And did we forget to mention the CenturyLink ONE GIG HIGH SPEED INTERNET availability for this community? This is the FASTEST internet connection in Idaho! Ethernet ports located in each of the bedrooms. . Easy maintenance free exterior with the lowest HOA fee around which is $35/month. This fee takes care of lawn and common area maintenance. This is an ideal investment opportunity for a first time home buyer or an investor looking for a stable location to put your money. Rents in these units are around $1650 to $1800 per month.

458 S 3rd W Unit #458, Sugar City
Start Your Search